Hidden Harmonies China Blog

As China Re-Awakens, Finding New Harmonies in a Brave New World...

Beijing University Professor Fan Gang: Rising labor cost in China not a worry

by 173 Comments

It’s Labor Day in the U.S.! There has been a lot of sensationalism in the West regarding rising labor costs in China (i.e. Foxconn, Honda, etc.). Just to keep things in perspective, we are talking about instances of factory workers making something like $100 a month to making $150 a month in the richer coastal cities. While it is a whopping 50% jump, that $50/month is easily absorbed by other factors as explained by an economist and Beijing University Professor Fan Gang. He is also Director of China’s National Economic Research Institute, Secretary-General of the China Reform Foundation, and a former member of the Monetary Policy Committee of the People’s Bank of China.

I have read too many “dumbed down” and sensationalized articles in the West about the labor cost issue in China. Here is an intelligent (and I also dare say “boring”, as in Daniel Schorr’s “boring”) view from China (appeared in China Daily as, “Is low-wage China disappearing?“):

Is low-wage China disappearing?
By Fan Gang (chinadaily.com.cn)
Updated: 2010-08-31 13:29

BEIJING — Reports about labor shortages, wage disputes, and wage increases for migrant workers in China have abounded of late. They naturally raised concerns, or expectations, that China’s labor-cost advantages may be disappearing.

It is my hope that China’s comparative advantage as a low-wage producer does disappear — the sooner the better. But why should I, a Chinese economist, wish to see China’s competitiveness reduced through rising labor costs? After all, when a country still lacks real advantages, such as higher education, efficient markets and enterprises, and a capacity for innovation, it needs something like low wages to maintain growth.

While cheap labor has been a key factor in generating high growth over the past three decades, it has also contributed to profound income disparities, especially in recent years. And persistent, widening inequality might cause social crises that could interrupt growth and damage competitiveness. China must avoid such a scenario, and if wages could increase in some meaningful way, it would indicate that the economy might finally reach the next stage of development, during which income disparities would be narrowed.

Unfortunately, China has not yet reached that point — and will not any time soon. Agriculture remains the main source of income for more than 30% of China’s labor force, compared to less than 2% in the United States or 6% in South Korea. Another 30% of the labor force comprises migrant workers, who have doubled their incomes by moving from agriculture to the industrial and service sectors.

Although migrant workers earn only about $1,500 per year on average, the income gap between them and agricultural laborers provides a powerful incentive for the latter to try to find better-paid non-farm jobs. Naturally, this competition in the labor market suppresses non-farm wages: whereas labor productivity in non-farm sectors increased by 10-12% annually in the past 15 years, migrant workers’ real wages have increased by only 4-6% per year. As a result, income disparity between low-end labor, on the one hand, and professionals and investors, on the other, has also increased.

All this means that the process of industrialization in China still has a long way to go. To reduce farm labor to 10% of the labor force (the point at which, judging by historical experience elsewhere, China may achieve worker-farmer wage equilibrium), the economy needs to create about 150 million new non-farm jobs.

Even if the economy continues to grow at 8% per year, China might need 20-30 years to reallocate agricultural laborers and reach “full employment.” But this requires generating eight million new jobs every year, including five million for farmers leaving the countryside.

During this long process of industrialization, wages will increase gradually, but it is very unlikely that they will grow at the same rate as labor productivity. This is bad news for reducing income inequality, as capital gains and high-end wages may grow much faster. But it should be the good news for competitiveness, because Chinese wages will remain relatively low in terms of “wage efficiency.”

Indeed, the wage increases of recent years have not changed the basic cost structure of Chinese companies. An analysis by Goldman Sachs shows that, despite real wage gains, the share of labor costs in total manufacturing costs is lower than it was in 2001 — a trend that continued in the first half of 2010.

To prevent serious social tension, China’s government (at various levels) has begun to intervene by enforcing higher minimum wages, in addition to investing in a social safety net for the poor. In some provinces, minimum wages have increased by more than 30%. But the minimum wage is normally much lower than the effective wage, and thus has not changed the fundamental relationship between wages and labor productivity.

Nevertheless, artificial wage increases enforced by government policies could slow down the process of labor reallocation and make some “surplus labor” permanent. Income disparities will not be fundamentally altered until the market equilibrium wage inches upwards sufficiently to create labor demand at decent wage levels.

So will companies, both multinationals and Chinese, leave for Vietnam, Bangladesh, or Mozambique? Perhaps. But that will happen only if the other countries’ wages are relatively more efficient (i.e., productivity there is ultimately higher than in China), and not just because Chinese nominal wages go up. For now, however, this does not seem to be the case in general.

Evidence that China’s wage efficiency remains high relative to other developing countries comes in the form of continued growth in inflows of foreign direct investment over the past 12 months, despite wage increases. In July, for example, FDI increased by 29.2% year on year, much higher than the global average. There may be many factors behind China’s strong FDI performance, but it does mean that the nominal wage increase itself may not lower the capital gains that concern investors most.

In any case, the Chinese wage story is much more complicated than it might seem. Nominal wages may increase, while real wages stagnate, owing to higher inflation. Even if real wages increase in some coastal cities, “surplus labor” could keep the national average flat. And even a real wage increase on the national level will not undermine competitiveness if labor productivity grows still faster.

So the conclusion seems to be that wage growth will not threaten China’s competitiveness in the next 10 or even 20 years. As China will not complete the process of reallocating workers from agriculture to more modern economic sectors any time soon, it should remain a cost-competitive economy for the foreseeable future.

Reader Interactions

Comments

  11. онлайн казино, dreranna.com предоставляет уникальную возможность погрузиться в
    мир в азартные игры, находясь у
    себя дома.

  14. 1xbet зеркало, 1xbet предоставляет возможность развлекаться даже при неудобствах.

    Доступ к 1xbet зеркало без проблем.

    Visit my webpage … 1xbet-zpdbe.cfd

  16. 1xbet официальный сайт, 1xbet предлагает разнообразный выбор азартных ставок.
    Пользователи могут увлекаться восторгом от игры в любое
    время.

    My webpage – 1xbet-tm2tm.blog

  29. зеркало 1xbet, 1xbet позволяет сделать ставки в любое время.
    Вход через альтернативные сайты существенно упрощает процесс.

    my webpage 1xbet-x4j7e.sbs

  33. Lucky Jet Game,
    Lucky Jet is an exciting entertainment that offers thrilling adventures for players.

    Boasting its unique mechanics, it entices the attention of players worldwide.

  39. зеркало 1xbet, 1xbet представляет собой альтернативный доступ к платформе для
    ставок.

  53. crypto casino, btc casino offers an exciting atmosphere for
    players seeking excitement. With blockchain powering the games,
    users enjoy security and straightforwardness. Join the revolution in online gambling!

  65. Official JayPlaysGames, JayPlaysGames delivers
    captivating content that enthralls gamers.

    With in-depth reviews and humorous commentary, every video is a treasure for enthusiasts.
    Join the community and immerse yourself in the
    fun!

  70. Are you looking to seek a way to Download mp3 free, https://mp3.cc/?
    Nowadays, numerous platforms offer easy access to music without payment.

    Ensure to choose reliable sources for secure downloads.
    Enjoy your favorite tracks!

  72. You can certainly see your enthusiasm in the work
    you write. The arena hopes for even more passionate writers
    such as you who are not afraid to say how they believe.
    At all times go after your heart.

  74. My brother suggested I might like this web site.
    He used to be entirely right. This publish actually made my
    day. You can not imagine just how so much time I had spent for this information! Thanks!

  75. Do you mind if I quote a couple of your posts as long as I provide credit and sources back to your
    site? My website is in the exact same niche as yours and my users would certainly benefit from some
    of the information you provide here. Please let me know
    if this okay with you. Cheers!

  76. {Οι ειδήσεις βοηθούν τον αναγνώστη να παρακολουθεί {σημαντικές εξελίξεις|καθημερινές αλλαγές|ενδιαφέροντα θέματα} με απλό και κατανοητό τρόπο.} {Ένα καλό ενημερωτικό κείμενο πρέπει να
    προσφέρει χρήσιμο πλαίσιο, χωρίς υπερβολές ή δύσκολη γλώσσα.} {Έτσι, η
    ενημέρωση γίνεται πιο ευχάριστη και πιο πρακτική για την καθημερινή
    ζωή.}

    {Οι θετικές ειδήσεις μπορούν να αναδείξουν {πρόοδο|νέες
    ιδέες|καλές πρωτοβουλίες}.} {Με
    σωστή δομή και φιλικό ύφος, κάθε είδηση γίνεται
    χρήσιμη πηγή γνώσης για όσους θέλουν να μένουν ενημερωμένοι.}

  77. {Οι ειδήσεις βοηθούν τον αναγνώστη να παρακολουθεί {σημαντικές εξελίξεις|καθημερινές αλλαγές|ενδιαφέροντα θέματα} με απλό
    και κατανοητό τρόπο.} {Ένα καλό ενημερωτικό κείμενο
    πρέπει να προσφέρει χρήσιμο πλαίσιο, χωρίς υπερβολές ή δύσκολη γλώσσα.} {Έτσι, η ενημέρωση γίνεται πιο ευχάριστη και πιο πρακτικήγια την
    καθημερινή ζωή.}

    {Οι θετικές ειδήσεις μπορούν να αναδείξουν {πρόοδο|νέες ιδέες|καλές πρωτοβουλίες}.} {Με σωστή δομή και φιλικό
    ύφος, κάθε είδηση γίνεται ενδιαφέρουσα πηγή γνώσης
    για όσους θέλουν να μένουν ενημερωμένοι.}

  78. {Οι ειδήσεις βοηθούν τον αναγνώστη να παρακολουθεί {σημαντικές εξελίξεις|καθημερινές αλλαγές|ενδιαφέροντα
    θέματα} με απλό και κατανοητό τρόπο.} {Ένα καλό
    ενημερωτικό κείμενο πρέπει να
    προσφέρει σαφήνεια, χωρίς υπερβολές
    ή δύσκοληγλώσσα.} {Έτσι, η ενημέρωση γίνεται πιο
    ευχάριστη και πιο πρακτική για την καθημερινή
    ζωή.}

    {Οι θετικές ειδήσεις μπορούν να αναδείξουν {πρόοδο|νέες ιδέες|καλές πρωτοβουλίες}.} {Με σωστή δομή και φιλικό ύφος, κάθε
    είδηση γίνεται αξιόπιστη πηγή γνώσης για
    όσους θέλουν να μένουν ενημερωμένοι.}

  79. winx96 casino, winx96 casino
    offers an exciting gaming experience for players worldwide.
    With numerous games to choose from, including slots, it’s easy to pick your favorite.

    The site ensures privacy of transactions, making it secure for everyone.

  88. It’s really a nice and useful piece of information. I am happy
    that you just shared this useful info with us. Please stay us up
    to date like this. Thanks for sharing.

  90. Wonderful blog! I found it while surfing around on Yahoo News.
    Do you have any suggestions on how to get listed in Yahoo
    News? I’ve been trying for a while but I never seem to get
    there! Many thanks

  91. en iyi bahis bonusları, savoy-casino, oyuncuların kazanma şansını artırmak
    için önemli fırsatlar sunar. Bu, bahis siteleri, yeni cazip
    teklifler sağlar. Her bahis sever, bu avantajları değerlendirmelidir.

  92. Hi there to all, how is all, I think every
    one is getting more from this site, and your views are fastidious designed for new people.

  93. You’ve made some really good points there.
    I looked on the web to find out more about the issue and found most
    individuals will go along with your views on this site.

  94. Useful information. Lucky me I found your website by
    chance, and I am stunned why this accident did not happened earlier!
    I bookmarked it.

  95. You possibly get some pictures scurry through your brain when I tell you that BlackTube is a free tube dedicated to evil bitches.

    These girls are bad in the traditional porno way, for one thing, because they double fist
    with a couple of girls in a group scene, get pounded up the ass by a solid, throbbing BBC, and do all
    kinds of shit your mommy told you great ladies don’t do.
    https://museum.skeiron.com.ua/agent/aliciabanning0/ https://gigscenes.com/author/barbrapenningt/

  96. LC88 là nền tảng cá cược trực tuyến được
    cộng đồng game thủ tin tưởng nhờ hệ sinh thái
    giải trí đa dạng và hệ thống vận hành cực kỳ ổn định.
    Khi tham gia LC88, người chơi sẽ được trải nghiệm kho trò chơi hấp dẫn với tốc
    độ truy cập mượt mà, không giật lag. Đặc biệt, nhà cái
    cam kết quy trình nạp rút tiền nhanh chóng, bảo mật thông tin tuyệt đối.
    Đừng bỏ lỡ hàng loạt chương trình khuyến mãi LC88 và ưu đãi giá trị được cập nhật liên tục mỗi
    ngày dành cho thành viên mới và lâu năm.

  97. It’s a pity you don’t have a donate button! I’d
    most certainly donate to this excellent blog! I guess for now
    i’ll settle for bookmarking and adding your RSS feed to my Google account.
    I look forward to fresh updates and will talk about this blog with my Facebook group.
    Chat soon!

  98. Someone essentially assist to make severely posts I might state.
    This is the first time I frequented your website page and so far?

    I surprised with the research you made to create this actual publish extraordinary.
    Great task!

  100. Please let me know if you’re looking for a article writer for your blog.
    You have some really good articles and I feel I would
    be a good asset. If you ever want to take some of the load off, I’d love to write some
    articles for your blog in exchange for a link back to mine.
    Please shoot me an email if interested. Regards!

  101. Hi there! This article could not be written much better!
    Reading through this article reminds me of my previous roommate!
    He always kept preaching about this. I am going to send this article to him.
    Pretty sure he’s going to have a very good read. Many thanks for
    sharing!

  102. Someone essentially lend a hand to make seriously posts I’d state.
    This is the very first time I frequented your web page and up
    to now? I amazed with the research you made to create this
    actual submit amazing. Wonderful job!

  103. First of all I want to say superb blog! I had a quick question that I’d like to ask if you don’t mind.

    I was interested to find out how you center yourself and clear your
    thoughts prior to writing. I have had a hard time clearing my thoughts in getting my ideas
    out there. I do take pleasure in writing however it just seems like the first 10 to 15 minutes tend to be
    wasted simply just trying to figure out how to begin. Any suggestions or
    tips? Kudos!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *